| 2024 (tie) | CM/HPMC Frankie CH | Florencio I x Aronja/ A Jungle Prince | 8.0 | Catherine Haddad | Catherine Haddad |
| Frida Kahlo QC | Franklin x Rhosemary/Rosentanz | 8.0 | Jonathan Clark and Quinnten Alston | Jonathan Clark and Quinnten Alston |
| 2023 (tie) | BELLE DE RUBIN AVF | Bon Coeur-Ravenrubin/Rubinstein I | 7.83 | Nancy Cross | Dr. Anke Ott-Young |
| JHUNO | Jovian-Santana/Sandro Hit | 7.83 | Maurine Swanson | Frieder Heilman |
| 2022 | DU PRIMERO | Dubarry-Donatella/Don Primero | 8.0 | Dr. Susan E. Heiken | Meg Williams |
| 2021 (tie) | DANTE'S PRINCESS | Dante Weltino-Wie Liebe/Wolkenstein II | 8.16 | Marne Martin-Tucker | Jerry Glynne |
| SARBONNE | Sir Caletto-Filigree S/Freestyle | 8.16 | Silverhorne Sporthorses, LLC | Silverhorne Sporthorses, LLC |
| 2020 | FABIENNE QC | Franziskus-Royal Celeste FH/Royal Classic | 8.0 | Kimberley Dougherty | Jonathan Clark and Quinnten Alston |
| 2019 | ROCKELLE | Rotspon-Wiesling/Wolkentanz I | 8.33 | Angela Mirarchi | Angela Mirarchi |
| 2018 | LAURETTE | (Londonderry-Winnifer/Wolkentanz I) | 8.16 | Jonathan Clark & Quinnten Alston | Jo Ann Thomas, Ore. |
| 2017 | HPMC DAKAR MF | (Don Principe-SPS Brisbane/Belissimo M) | 8.0 | Maryanna Haymon | Hans-Heinrich Bruening, Ger. |
| 2016 (tie) | RELEVÉ HTF | (Royal Prince-EM Comtesse/Cordoba) | 7.83 | Hilltop Farm | Hilltop Farm |
| REVELRY THF | (Royal Blend-EM Gabriela/Grundstein I) | 7.83 | Talley Ruhle | Talley Ruhle |
| WROYAL HEIR | (Widmark-Divinia/Don Frederico) | 7.83 | Rebecca Lewison | Meg Williams |
| 2015 | WIKTORIA FH | (Wolkentanz II-EM Del Amika/Donnerhall) | 8.16 | Eliza Rutherford | Eliza Rutherford, Vt. |
| 2014 | EMC STILETTO MRF | (Sir Donnerhall I-Britania/Bordeaux) | 8.33 | Maple Run Farm | Maple Run Farm, Wis. |
| 2013 | LADY IN RED KS | (Liberty Gold-EM Berlina/Brentano II) | 8.00 | Karan & Tom Schwencer | Karan & Tom Schwencer, Md. |
| 2012 | FURST DAY LIGHT | (Furst Impression-Amelia Bedelia/Anhaltiner E) | 7.83 | Mary Manning | Mary Manning, N.C. |
| 2011 | ROCOCO OSH | (Rotspon-Parisienne/Prince Thatch xx) | 8.33 | Mary Beth Stanton, DVM | Stephanie Hagins, Fla. |
| 2010 | EMC LUCETTE | (Liberty Gold-EM Aluette/Argentan I) | 8.16 | Jo Ann Thomas | Jo Ann Thomas, Ore. |
| 2009 | PAULEAH | (Paparazzo-Miranda/Maronjo) | 8.33 | George Toccalino | Louise Lovett, Fla. |
| 2008 | RONDALET | (Rotspon-EM Donna Lady/ Donnerhall) | 8.16 | Jan Voytilla | Westbrook Farms, Can. |
| 2007 | WOLKENSTANZA MLW | (Wolkentanz I-Rohanna/ Rohdiamant) | 8.50 | Mary Lou Winn | Mary Lou Winn, Fla. |
| 2006 | COURVOISIER V.S.O.P. | (Contucci-SPS Wilhelmine/Walt Disney I) | 7.94 | Brenda and Peter Hansen | Brenda and Peter Hansen, Del. |
| 2005 (tie) | EMC FALLON SLH | (Fabriano-EM Weltlady/Weltruhm) | 8.00 | Nona Henderson | Nona Henderson, Wash |
| EMC WOLKA | (Wolkenstein II-Malina/Matcho x) | 8.00 | Jack W. Robinson | Joern Doescher, Ger. |
| 2004 (tie) | DONATA L | (Del Piero-SPS Ballerina/Bolero) | 8.00 | Leatherdale Farms | Peter Mahler, Ger. |
| EM HOCHKARAT | (Hohenstein-SPS Destemona/De Niro) | 8.00 | Marion Dresel O'Connor | Hans-Guenter Berner, Ger. |
| 2003 (tie) | EMC AUDREY | (A Jungle Prince-SPS Faye/Forrest xx) | 8.16 | Betsy LaBelle | Barbara Dzaack, Ger. |
| EM MARCELLINA WF | (Magic-EM Frederika/Feiner Stern) | 8.16 | William D. Mulholland | William D. Mulholland, Ont. |
| EMC RHEINSTONE | (Regazzoni-SPS Flick Flack/Feiner Stern) | 8.16 | H. Russell Hart | Horst Erxleben, Ger. |
| 2002 (tie) | EM FANTASIA FUERSTIN R | (Fuerst Gotthard-Libra/Lundberg) | 8.00 | Donna Salmont | Rainbow Equus Meadows, Calif. |
| ISABEL | (Induc-EM Winsome/World Cup IV) | 8.00 | Elizabeth Klebe | Elizabeth Klebe, Fla. |
| EM MUSETTA | (Magic-Willa/World Cup IV) | 8.00 | William D. Mulholland | William D. Mulholland, Ont. |
| 2001 | D'ALLEGRA | (Davignon-SPS Allegra/Allround) | 8.00 | Marefield Meadows | Marefield Meadows, Va. |
| 2000 | EM MATHILDA | (Magic-EM Frederika/Feiner Stern) | 8.00 | William D. Mulholland | William D. Mulholland, Ont. |
| 1999 (tie) | BRIANNA | (Bordeaux-Auf Wiedersehen/Adios III) | 7.83 | Kathy Priest | Bridlewood Farm, Ky. |
| EM FIRST PIK | (Wertherson-Pik Dame/Pik Knig) | 7.83 | Suzanne Quarles | Suzanne Quarles, Md. |
| 1998 | EM REGAN | (Ravallo-SPS Bounty/Bolero) | 8.00 | Marefield Meadows | Marefield Meadows, Va. |
| 1997 (tie) | PICSANABEL | (Picard-Corcoran Belle xx/Gebomo xx) | 8.00 | Betty Karl | Catherine Biederbach, Calif. |
| EM WELKIN | (World Cup IV-SPS Bummy/Bolero) | 8.00 | William D. Mulholland | William D. Mulholland, Ont. |
| EM WONDER GIRL | (Wonderful-SPS Comtesse/Cordial) | 8.00 | Leatherdale Farms | Reinhard Brandt, Ger. |
| 1996 | FONTEYN | (Werther-Starrcrest Lady xx/Pack Trip xx) | 8.16 | Anne Schmidt & Martha Moody | Anne Schmidt, Ore. |
| 1995 | EM WHIMSICAL | (Wertherson-Jet Set/Jet Stream xx) | 8.16 | Suzanne Quarles | Suzanne Quarles, Md. |
| 1994 | STOP MAKIN SENSE | (Sanwalt-Sasquatch Baby xx/HeÕs A Baby xx) | 8.16 | Noelle Nickeson | Sandra Brown Tull, Mich. |
